Jill Chasson Examines Employer Liability for Nonemployee Harassment in HR Laws

A recent sexual harassment lawsuit against an Arizona senior living operator reinforces a key lesson for residential care, hospitality, and other client service employers: they can face potentially significant liability for harassment committed by nonemployees. In her latest HR Laws article, Partner Jill Chasson broke down the resulting consent decree and its implications for workplace policies and complaint handlings. Jill analyzed the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) case against Christian Care Management Inc., which allegedly failed to investigate multiple complaints about a male resident’s sexually explicit comments and vulgar behavior toward female employees. The case resulted in a $250,000 settlement, mandated policy changes and training, and ongoing EEOC oversight. Jill emphasized that employers may be liable for nonemployee harassment if they know or should know about the...

Read MoreRead More

John Kelly Named to PHOENIX Magazine’s 2026 Top Lawyers List

Widely respected as a seasoned neutral in high-stakes business, employment, and serious injury disputes, Partner John Kelly recently claimed a spot on PHOENIX Magazine’s Top Lawyers list for his outstanding work in Arbitration & Mediation. The magazine develops its annual list of the Valley’s standout legal professionals through an extensive peer-review process, inviting thousands of active Arizona attorneys to nominate the local lawyers they consider the best across 39 practice areas. Editors then select the top 10% to 20% in each category, reflecting the respect and esteem honorees have earned among their peers. A member of the highly selective National Academy of Distinguished Neutrals, John is a skilled arbitrator, mediator, and litigator who guides companies toward practical resolutions in complex commercial and regulatory matters. He conducts settlement...

Read MoreRead More

Partner Bo Dul Named to Az Business Magazine’s Most Influential Women of 2026

An accomplished leader known for her extensive impact across election, public, and political law, Partner Sambo “Bo” Dul was featured in Az Business magazine’s 2026 list of the Most Influential Women in Arizona Business. The publication’s editorial board and a panel of past recipients selected Bo as one of 34 honorees from a field of more than 2,200 women in consideration. “I’m humbled to be part of such an outstanding group of leaders who are actively bettering Arizona’s communities and creating opportunities for future generations,” said Bo. “This recognition is a reminder that my dedication to public service and free and fair elections is making a real, meaningful difference in our state.” In addition to the Most Influential Women honor, Bo's leadership has been celebrated through numerous...

Read MoreRead More

Jill Chasson Breaks Down New Court Guidance on PIPs & Adverse Employment Actions in HR Laws

Performance improvement plans (PIPs) remain a common tool for addressing workplace performance and conduct issues, but evolving discrimination standards have raised new questions about when PIPs could trigger liability concerns for employers. In the July issue of HR Laws, Partner Jill Chasson examined a new U.S. First Circuit Court of Appeals decision that offered helpful guidance on how courts may evaluate PIPs under the post-Muldrow standard for adverse employment actions. Jill analyzed the recent Walsh v. HNTB case, which involved a long-tenured employee who claimed her placement on a PIP supported age discrimination and constructive discharge claims. The court found that the PIP did not change the employee’s pay, title, responsibilities, or opportunities, and therefore did not qualify as an adverse employment action. Still, the court affirmed...

Read MoreRead More

Jill Chasson Examines Arizona Federal Court Ruling on Commission Forfeiture in HR Laws

Commission agreements often require workers to be actively employed on their payout date to receive commissions, putting earned pay at risk if an employee departs before then. In the April issue of HR Laws, Partner Jill Chasson explored a new Arizona federal court decision that casts doubt on whether those provisions are sustainable long term for local employers. In her article, Jill analyzed a case involving a mortgage loan originator who resigned before certain commissions were paid, even though the loans had already closed. The court determined the employee could not recover the payment under Arizona’s wage statute, yet still found the forfeiture provision unconscionable under Arizona contract law. This decision confirmed that employers cannot withhold commissions once the work to earn them is complete and...

Read MoreRead More

Coppersmith Brockelman Named Law Firm of the Year Finalist in Az Business’ 2026 Excellence in Law Awards

Az Business recently recognized Coppersmith Brockelman as a finalist for Law Firm of the Year in the Small and Medium Size Firm category at the 2026 Excellence in Law Awards — highlighting its commitment to modern legal leadership that goes beyond cases won and contracts closed to drive purposeful progress across the state. The annual Excellence in Law Awards celebrate the top attorneys and firms whose work shapes organizations, strengthens communities, and advances meaningful initiatives both within and beyond the legal practice. The Excellence in Law distinction follows the firm’s repeat appearance on Best Lawyers® and U.S. News & World Report’s 2026 Best Law Firms List. Coppersmith Brockelman is a Phoenix-based law firm with national reach, known for its practical, creative counsel and litigation across a wide range...

Read MoreRead More